Music is more than bubble bath

Last night, prompted by a mixture of curiosity and vanity, I did this BBC musicality test. The test and this accompanying piece are eager to kill some of the myths that infest our social attitudes to music. Far too many people still see “musicality” in, if you’ll forgive me, almost Calvinistic terms: you have the Elect (sprinkled with the fairy dust of talent) and the Damned (a.k.a. the tone-deaf). In reality there are many measures of musicality besides the ability to “hold a tune”, and the BBC study tests awareness of genre and sensitivity to rhythm, as well as asking participants to fill out a long questionnaire.

Anyway, at the end of all this my scores were reassuringly high, but I scored worryingly low on “emotional connection” to music. The questionnaire had asked if I often used music to motivate or relax me, or if music often evoked memories of people or places for me – and my answers were lukewarm. However. At the risk of sounding defensive, I quibble with the conclusion that this makes me less emotionally connected to music.

Music does motivate me and it does relax me, but that’s not, in general, why I listen to it. It’s a useful side-effect of the fact that I listen to music for its own sake. I know plenty of people who use music to motivate themselves, for instance while doing exercise, and in some cases they couldn’t care less what the music is, as long as the mood and the BPM fit the bill. For relaxation purposes, similarly, any old whale-song will do. But for me, it does music a disservice to treat it as a means to an end – a substitute for Red Bull or bubble bath.

By the same token, I am perfectly capable of being moved and transported by music, but don’t necessarily associate its emotional wrench with a particular event in my own life. Music can be sad without being sad about anything.

This entry was posted in Music. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Music is more than bubble bath

  1. I also sat the test and reassuringly scored highly. I remember being similarly irritated by those questions as I only ever tend to listen to music with a view to becoming completely immersed in it. Great music to me stimulates and consumes rather than relaxes and soothes.

  2. Pingback: Musicians and dog whistles | Edward Randell

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s